| # | Track | Artist | Album / Comment |
|---|
| 1 | come on! let's boogie to the elf dance | sufjan stevens | |
| 2 | getting ready for christmas day | paul simon | |
| 3 | christmas wrappings | the waitresses | |
| 4 | got something for you | best coast, wavves | the christmas gig |
| 5 | christmakwanzakah | the dan band | |
| 6 | kindle a flame in her heart | los campesinos! | |
| 7 | you'll never find my christmas | bishop allen | the christmas gig |
| 8 | all that i want | the weepies | |
| 9 | christmas (baby please come home) | death cab for cutie | |
| 10 | santa stole my lady | fitz and the tantrums | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 11 | christmas will be just another lonely day | wye oak | stereogum: new indie christmas mp3s for 2011 |
| 12 | angels we have heard on high | the rondelles | shiny nickels & loose change |
| 13 | angels we have heard on high | quiet company | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 14 | i want a hippopotamus for christmas | gayla peevey | |
| 15 | clint frostwood | chillaz | kevin & bean's swallow my eggnog |
| 16 | mr. heatmiser | big bad voodoo daddy | |
| 17 | sometimes you have to work on christmas (sometimes) | harvey danger | kevin & bean's santa's swingin' sack |
| 18 | xmas time (oh yeah) | barenaked ladies | kevin & bean's santa's swingin' sack |
| 19 | get down for the holidays | jenny o. | the christmas gig |
| 20 | must be santa | bob dylan | christmas in the heart |
| 21 | tiny tree christmas | guster | the christmas gig |
| 22 | un regalo para mi (a present for me) | ceci bastida | the christmas gig |
| 23 | stay in | army navy | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 24 | it doesn't feel like christmas | toad the wet sprocket | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 25 | it's christmas | polyphonic spree | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 26 | I'll be home for christmas (feat. scarlett johannsson) | dean martin | stereogum: new indie christmas mp3s for 2011 |
| 27 | wonderful christmas time | the bandana splits | stereogum: new indie christmas mp3s for 2011 |
| 28 | all i wonderful christmas is you | summer camp | stereogum: new indie christmas mp3s for 2011 |
| 29 | christmas wrappings | save ferris | kevin & bean's santa's swingin' sack |
| 30 | christmas at ground zero | weird al yankovic | kevin & bean's last christmas |
| 31 | all my bells are ringing | lenka | |
| 32 | you never come home for christmas | caitlin rose and keegan dewitt | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 33 | we're going to the country | sufjan stevens | |
| 34 | joy to the world | seryn | 2011 paste christmas sampler |
| 35 | maybe this christmas | ron sexsmith | |
| 36 | silent night | class actress | |
